What Barry did with shitty o lines and QBs and horrible defensive is really fucking impressive , I can’t picture any other RB doing what he did with those offensive line and I loved Walter .
[Reply]

Calvin too
[Reply]

Stafford got a Championship
[Reply]

LOL at Emmett Smith.

ONE OF THESE THINGS IS NOT LIKE THE OTHERS...
[Reply]

Emmitt Smith is not a top 10 back unless the only criteria is longevity.
[Reply]

I was gonna say this but I thought I would be on an island. Maybe top ten workhorse back
[Reply]

You didn't watch the first 2/3 of Payton's career.
[Reply]

You guys are going to get Clay to post another novel on here about how much Emmitt Smith and Troy Aikman make him erect
[Reply]

He's not wrong, but the Twitter tard who twitted this is gayer than cum on a mustache
[Reply]

I P misses one open hole during his 2nd preseason game- and tards are ready to cut him-lol

Good lord, you guys are high maintenance.
[Reply]

lol yes he is, he was really good at running back. It's kind of dumb to say a running back's production doesn't count if they had a good oline. I guess Priest Holmes sucked then.
[Reply]

Really good =/= top 10 ever.
[Reply]

being #1 all time in rushing yards is going to land you in the top 10 ever on most people's list. I hated the cowboys in the 90's, everybody in my school was on that bandwagon and that made me hate them more but to say he definitely shouldn't be on a top 10 list is just hating for the sake of hating.
[Reply]

that's a big yikes

Pat saw it
[Reply]

But … he doesn’t.

If you compare him to the guys on the list, he doesn’t stack up. If you put Emmett Smith on teams like the ones Barry Sanders thrived on, he’s a nothing burger. Etc.

He was a durable back with good vision. A really good player. But not an all-time great, or at least not as good as any of the players below him on this list, and not as good as players not included.
[Reply]