Originally Posted by suzzer99:
It seems like Clark has given up on going for one last payday. I was hoping he'd come in motivated this year.
May be why his play has declined even further. Knows with the felony charges and his play recently it's his last year of making significant money from us and almost definitely any other team so he's mentally checked out. [Reply]
Originally Posted by Pasta Little Brother:
The same people patting themselves on the back for not wanting Clark wanted Clowney and that dude is a turd as well :-)
Clowney cost $29 million over 3 seasons and a 3rd round pick + some roster chaff.
Clark cost $65 million over those same 3 seasons + a first and second round pick.
This really the argument you want to make? [Reply]
Originally Posted by DJ's left nut:
Clowney cost $29 million over 3 seasons and a 3rd round pick + some roster chaff.
Clark cost $65 million over those same 3 seasons + a first and second round pick.
This really the argument you want to make?
Ideally you don't do either of those trades, but I'd still take Clark over Clowney even with those parameters based on the hindsight of Clark actually being a key contributor to the Super Bowl run. Clowney just seems like an even shittier DE version of Hammy Twatkins [Reply]
Also based on the fact that if we hadn't traded that 2019 pick we most likely pick one of the shitty DL from the bottom of that first round based on all our draft visits. Or the degenerate CB we ended up with anyway. [Reply]
Originally Posted by Superturtle:
Ideally you don't do either of those trades, but I'd still take Clark over Clowney even with those parameters based on the hindsight of Clark actually being a key contributor to the Super Bowl run. Clowney just seems like an even shittier DE version of Hammy Twatkins
I said when we made the trade (and even when he was dog-shit into November of '19) that flags fly forever and if Clark was instrumental in a SB, it's hard to call the trade a failure.
But right now, if I could trade Clark for Clowney, I'd do it in a heartbeat. Straight player for player I'd probably still take Clowney and when you factor in their respective contracts and cap hits, it's not a close question.
Last year was a wash at best. Clowney was better when he was on the field, but he wasn't on the field enough (as is his custom). Then again, I'm not sure what Clark actually provided when he was.
I mean the only benefit Frank Clark has provided this team was a 6 week stretch (ish) at the end of 2019. We could argue just how critical he was in 'closing' wins that were largely decided by the time the sack in question happened (two of which were coverage sacks), but every play counted in the Super Bowl and he made one. So that makes the deal a 'win' in the same way Watkins deal was a win - a bad acquisition in a vacuum that was made palatable by a championship.
Clark is bad. He's been bad for awhile. Injury, motivation, diet - whatever. He's just a bad football player and there's little indication that this is going to change anytime soon. [Reply]
Originally Posted by Superturtle:
Also based on the fact that if we hadn't traded that 2019 pick we most likely pick one of the shitty DL from the bottom of that first round based on all our draft visits. Or the degenerate CB we ended up with anyway.
Maybe.
But I remember one of 'The Franchise' episodes where Veach seemed really high on Rock Ya-Sin and CB was another clear need at the time, coming off the AFCCG debacle.
Wouldn't have surprised me if he was the pick. He's been...fine. But the fact that we took Hardman where we did also puts in the back of my mind that maybe AJ Brown would've been the guy and that one stings. [Reply]
Originally Posted by Hammock Parties:
Frank and Chris both getting raped over the coals today on CP.
We are stuck with Tyson Jackson and Eric Hicks at DE again.
Nah.
Chris Jones will fix his shit. He's going to be good out there.
He just couldn't tell which way was up by the 2nd quarter. He'll learn from it.
He deserves criticism for a shit game - it was as bad an effort as you'll see. But that's not who he is going forward or who he's been in the past. He's an elite talent and that will surface as the season goes along. [Reply]