Originally Posted by DRM08:
He also has starting OL and starting skill position players surrounding him. How would he do with 3rd stringers? You should be more concerned about the OL than QB.
Originally Posted by Mav:
Uh? Starting a qb before he is ready is a huge factor in the success and failure of qbs. Alex Smith started way too early and never became anything more than a game manager. Aaron Rodgers sat and is God. Geno Smith started way before he was ready and now is a fringe nfl player. Nothing wrong with sitting a guy who needs time.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Dan Marino started his rookie season and had a HOF career. Dan Marino was only maybe a couple months older than Patrick is now and Patrick will be turning 22 next month.
Dan Marino compared Patrick to himself with mobility so really it's any ones guess good or bad how he will respond. I believe Andy Reid has been throwing all kinds of mental aspects and testing him out in practice and he is passing every test thrown at him. So I don't think he will be ruined. I think he can handle being a starter this year just not first few games and ideally after the bye week.
Originally Posted by penbrook:
Smitty has won 22 out of his last 26 regular season games. I'm pretty sure not even Brady can do that in his last 26 regular season games
you have got to be fuckign kidding....
brady has won more fucking games, every season...than any other QB in history
put the fuckign pipe down with 'brady couldnt do that'
moron
2005 ---finished last half of season 7-2)
2006 ---12-4
2007--- 16-0
2008 - 1-0 (injured after)
Originally Posted by penbrook:
Smitty has won 22 out of his last 26 regular season games. I'm pretty sure not even Brady can do that in his last 26 regular season games
unless I am counting it wrong, smitty has won 21 out of his last 26 games, not 22 [Reply]
Originally Posted by Scooter Libby:
Chiefs planet: Alex Smith sucks! They should have cut him after the playoff game.
Chiefs planet now: I'd hope he's the best he's starting over a rookie and a 4 year guy.
Which is it?
So you take the extreme opinions of CP and make every poster that doesn't understand the point of your thread have to answer for them. That's a lazy way to try and defend yourself.
A lot of CP thinks Alex should start this year. It isn't contradictory at all to feel that the QB position needs to be upgraded but also think that Alex should clearly be the best QB on the roster at the moment. [Reply]
