ChiefsPlanet Mobile
Page 1 of 3
1 23 >
Media Center>A Perfect Circle - Eat the Elephant
MTG#10 07:40 PM 06-16-2018
This album is tremendous from beginning to end, in my opinion a masterpiece and I dont use that word loosely. I can count the number of albums I like every single song on with one hand and this is one of them. A lot more mellow than their other albums but that's part of the reason I like it so much...part of this is probably coming with age as I'm now pushing 40. The craziest part for me is I have never been a huge APC fan until this album...I always liked a handful of their songs but I never got into them much.

Maynard always provides thought provoking lyrics and this album is no different. I challenge anyone to listen to it from beginning to end a couple times and tell me you dont enjoy it. Dont give up after the first track. While I very much enjoy it, its probably the weakest of the album.

Every track is good but here are some of my favorites.










[Reply]
hometeam 08:36 PM 06-16-2018
yes
[Reply]
stumppy 08:47 PM 06-16-2018
Nice
[Reply]
WhiteWhale 09:38 PM 06-16-2018
I really like APC.

I think this album sucks.
[Reply]
MTG#10 09:43 PM 06-16-2018
Originally Posted by WhiteWhale:
I really like APC.

I think this album sucks.
You're dead to me.






Seriously though, how many times did you listen to it? I understand hardcore APC fans not liking it at first but give it a chance and open your mind to it. It's definitely different than their previous work but still a great album.
[Reply]
Archie Bunker 01:12 AM 06-17-2018
One of my favorite albums in awhile. Got to see them at Mizzou Arena in May, awesome show.
[Reply]
banecat 09:39 AM 06-17-2018
Awesome. I'm on the fringe, but I prefer them to Tool
[Reply]
hometeam 10:58 AM 06-17-2018
Originally Posted by banecat:
Awesome. I'm on the fringe, but I prefer them to Tool

[Reply]
MTG#10 03:08 PM 06-17-2018
Originally Posted by banecat:
Awesome. I'm on the fringe, but I prefer them to Tool
Originally Posted by hometeam:
:-)

As much as I love this album it doesn't come close to Tool's best for me. I do like it more than Undertow.
[Reply]
SuperChief 09:03 AM 06-19-2018
I really like the album. It's not my favorite of theirs, but it has some solid gems. I like that it's different than their others - it shows growth and a willingness to try and branch out from the norm.

The way you talk about this album (MTG) is how I feel about Thirteenth Step. Just a driving, engaging pulse throughout the whole thing. Beautiful.

That being said - no APC album comes close to Aenima, Lateralus, or 10,000 Days. I bet the new Tool album (whenever the fuck that comes out) is going to be insane. Very different, but still insane.
[Reply]
jd1020 10:04 AM 06-19-2018
Listened to the whole album on youtube and that "Hourglass" song can fuck right off. I get that musicians like the expand into different genres a bit after a while to try something new or whatever, but expanding into techno is the wrong move. It just sounds like pure shit. Isn't that type of shit basically his third band Puscifer? Keep that shit there Maynard so I dont have to instantly skip a song when it comes up in the cycle.

The rest of the album sounds good. Quite a bit different than the first 2 albums.

I'll buy it at some point.
[Reply]
ModSocks 10:11 AM 06-19-2018
My son loves APC. He's at that age where he's starting to get into music and APC is his first favorite band.

He has "Disillusioned" memorized.

As far as this album, i have to be in the mood for it.
[Reply]
SuperChief 11:12 AM 06-19-2018
Originally Posted by jd1020:
Listened to the whole album on youtube and that "Hourglass" song can **** right off. I get that musicians like the expand into different genres a bit after a while to try something new or whatever, but expanding into techno is the wrong move. It just sounds like pure shit. Isn't that type of shit basically his third band Puscifer? Keep that shit there Maynard so I dont have to instantly skip a song when it comes up in the cycle.

The rest of the album sounds good. Quite a bit different than the first 2 albums.

I'll buy it at some point.
It was very reminiscent of Puscifer, for sure. I get that it's not everyone's thing. Electronic-inspired music isn't really my bag either; however, I thought they did it well. Still a great APC ambiance.
[Reply]
banecat 03:30 PM 06-19-2018
Originally Posted by SuperChief:
It was very reminiscent of Puscifer, for sure. I get that it's not everyone's thing. Electronic-inspired music isn't really my bag either; however, I thought they did it well. Still a great APC ambiance.
Now there's a solid bad in Puscifer
[Reply]
jd1020 05:44 PM 06-19-2018
Originally Posted by SuperChief:
It was very reminiscent of Puscifer, for sure. I get that it's not everyone's thing. Electronic-inspired music isn't really my bag either; however, I thought they did it well. Still a great APC ambiance.
It just appeals to very few people.

Linkin Park tried it and never really recovered. Korn tried it and it was their least successful album. Chris Cornell tried it and while it ironically became his only solo album to debut in the top 10, it plummeted shortly after and got pretty negative reviews.

The biggest bands/names in the world cant sell that shit. Just stay away from the techno!
[Reply]
Page 1 of 3
1 23 >
Up