Only qb in the HOF with more INT’s than TD’s. Does he belong??
[Reply]

They already let Terrell Davis into the HOF.

They may as well put Reggie Ragland in the hall at this point.

Davis gets a bust. Eli gets a bust. Vince fucking Agnew gets a bust.
[Reply]

Last time he was benched he had a right to be pissed.

Geno's not a better QB than Eli and Webb should have started over Eli.
[Reply]

He ended the Pats' perfect season. He beat the GOAT twice in the Super Bowl. He had one of the most iconic, balls-out, incredible plays in Super Bowl history.

Fuck yes, he's a HOF quarterback.

God, you people can be short-sighted sometimes.
[Reply]

Eli Manning's record as a QB is perfectly balanced, 116-116, as all things should be.
[Reply]

That my friend is NO lie

I’ve always said he accomplished more with less raw physical talent than any other QB ever... never had a big arm, never could run a lick, wasn’t some big 6’5 linebacker size guy able to outmuscle someone to get a throw off

His success was purely based on his football IQ, but once he lost what little physical talent he began with... the IQ could no longer negate it
[Reply]

How can we talk the history of the NFL and not talk Joe Namath? The first 4000 yard season, the first AFL SB win (I know) that.....I GUARANTEE IT~~~

We have to put him that "he's special" category, like we do Gale Sayers and it looks like Lynn Swann.
[Reply]

When did he beat Mahomes in the Super Bowl once, much less twice?
[Reply]

I like Mahomes but "right now" he wouldn't make a zit on the butt of Tom Brady.
[Reply]

Why don’t you go back to eating your uncle’s asshole, bitch!!!
[Reply]

So, Scott Norwood, Hall of Famer? ... we should get the veterans committee on this oversight pronto
[Reply]

This should have been done years ago. Feel bad for the coach who got canned because he apparently benched Eli too soon for their fans liking. Eli is the most overrated QB in the history of the NFL. He won two super bowls thanks to elite defenses.
[Reply]

[Reply]

I'd still take him as a backup over Matt Moore, for that football IQ alone.
[Reply]

[Reply]