Can't get it up here north of the border but, through a wine distributer I am able to order a case. Would like to hear from someone who knows their stuff and has tried it before I order.
Originally Posted by Lilmrp117:
For rye, I'd go with willett 4 year as my favorite. Pikesville is also solid. on the more affordable end, high west double rye is great for about $30 where I shop.
I started as a scotch fan and it it took me a little while to get into bourbon but now i prefer bourbon. If you're trying to get into bourbon from scotch, I'd suggest starting with low rye or even no rye bourbon like makers mark. Or try a bourbon finished in sherry casks like belle meade sherry cask finish or port casks like angels envy. If you're looking for the taste of a smoky, peaty scotch, then there's not much in bourbon that's similar.
Since you're asking about rye though, you may prefer the higher rye bourbons. Try four roses single barrel, a store pick barrell proof is even better. High west American prarie is also good.
Thanks... I've had Templetons and High West. Several other off brands. Haven't tried Four Roses Single Barrel yet so I'll give that a try. There's a local whiskey distiller that does sherry casked whiskeys; J Reigers which I remember liking. I can't do things like Southern Comfort or cheap blends. I l like Bushmills Irish Whiskey super cold from the freezer, not a fan of Jamesons. [Reply]
Originally Posted by crayzkirk:
So, any recommendations on a good rye whisky? Also I like scotch better than bourbon.
IMO Rittenhouse Rye BIB is best bang for the buck at about 25.00 also look for EH Taylor straight rye. You can do worse and spend a lot more the 2 mentioned.
The store had $12 off Makers Mark Cask Strength so I bought some. I'm not a fan. I love higher alcohol bourbons, but this just doesn't have much flavor at all. I don't drink MM often so I'm not sure how this compares to their rest, but it isn't hitting me right. For reference, EH Taylor Barrel Proof is probably my favorite bourbon to drink. [Reply]
Originally Posted by bowener:
The store had $12 off Makers Mark Cask Strength so I bought some. I'm not a fan. I love higher alcohol bourbons, but this just doesn't have much flavor at all. I don't drink MM often so I'm not sure how this compares to their rest, but it isn't hitting me right. For reference, EH Taylor Barrel Proof is probably my favorite bourbon to drink.
It’s a straight wheat bourbon, which most people generally find “smoother.” I personally agree with you and find them more boring. I prefer some rye in my mash bill for more complex flavors and spice. [Reply]
