***Official Who to Start Thread*** - Page 22

Week 1 is looming folks. I'm giddy - like a schoolgirl. Anyway, I figured I would create a thread where people from the planet can post their rosters, and or tentative weekly starting rosters if they needed help.

I'm stuck @ #2 RB and #3 WR. Here is who I have starting in week one.

QB - Garrard @ Tenn
RB - Barber @ Cleveland
Portis @ NYG, TJones @ Miami, Selvin Young @ Oakland
WR - Colston v. TB
WR - Cotchery @ Miami
Bryant Johnson v. Zona, Hackett @ SD, Porter @ Tenn, Galloway @ NO
TE - Lee v. Minny
K - Jeff Reed v. Houston
JAX D @ Tenn.

Any help/guidance for my second RB and third WR would be appreciated.

Our information has yet to be posted on Yahoo! But, when it is I will be able to let you guys know some of the better FA WRs.
[Reply]

Originally Posted by Red Brooklyn:
that looks about right.

although... are we sure Carney is playing this week? And why are you leaning away from J. Jones against the C-boys? I'm just thinking that if Portis is banged up a bit (and the Giants D has been pretty solid) he might be an option instead of Portis. Lynch I'd start for sure.

I don't start Julius Jones because you never know when he's going to show up. He can run for 130 yards and then run for 4. This close to the playoffs....I'm not chancing anything.

Kicker really doesn't matter to me. I'll start Nedney if I have too.
[Reply]

Originally Posted by pestilenceaf23:
I don't start Julius Jones because you never know when he's going to show up. He can run for 130 yards and then run for 4. This close to the playoffs....I'm not chancing anything.

Kicker really doesn't matter to me. I'll start Nedney if I have too.

that makes sense. yeah, go with Portis.

I only wondered about Carney because I've got him on my roster too. He seems to do well week in and week out. If he's playing I usually start him.
[Reply]

I have to win to get in the playoffs this week. I'm wrestling with these two decisions...

Winslow or Shockey

This is going to sound crazy, but Dunn or Portis.

I know Portis seems like a no brainer, but he is banged up and facing the Giants, while Dunn is now getting most of the carries and facing the Saints...
[Reply]

Originally Posted by Deberg_1990:
Ok, which two:

McFadden
Addai
Forte
M Turner

I have a feeling McFadden is gonna have a big game again.

I would go with Forte and Addai
[Reply]

Originally Posted by Deberg_1990:

I have a feeling McFadden is gonna have a big game again.

I hope you're right cause I put Westbrook on the bench thinking he would. :-)

I have a two game lead and a playoff berth locked up so I rolled the dice with Westbrook being banged up.
[Reply]

I've started D-Bo all year but wonder how he'll do against Nnamdi Asomugha. QB's have been avoiding him all year.

L. Evans @ the 49er's
B. Berrian @ his old team, Bears
D. Hester @ the Viqueens.
Or I can pick up D. Mason @ the Bungles.

Which two? There's such a thing as over thinking and I'm doing it...I think.
[Reply]

Originally Posted by DJJasonp:
Favre vs. Denver's defense....OR Brees at Tampa Bay???

Favre. But the Jets screwed me against the Rams when they ran it all game. Coles had one catch. If Champ Bailey doesn't play, then I'd go Favre.
[Reply]

Originally Posted by Bill Lundberg:
I would go with Forte and Addai

Im gonna roll the dice and go with Addai and McFadden.

IM benching Forte and Turner this week.

I hope im right!!
[Reply]

Do I start Portis this week? He's banged up (again) and is running against the Ravens.

My main option would be putting in Fargas who has had a decent past couple weeks.
[Reply]

Originally Posted by Deberg_1990:
Im gonna roll the dice and go with Addai and McFadden.

IM benching Forte and Turner this week.

I hope im right!!

Ouch, that had to sting a little
[Reply]

Originally Posted by Spicy McHaggis:
Do I start Portis this week? He's banged up (again) and is running against the Ravens.

My main option would be putting in Fargas who has had a decent past couple weeks.

They say his knee is fine, but his neck was real sore. This is good news if his knee is not bothering him. So far I am expecting him to play, doesn't sound to serious.
[Reply]