***Official Who to Start Thread*** - Page 8

Week 1 is looming folks. I'm giddy - like a schoolgirl. Anyway, I figured I would create a thread where people from the planet can post their rosters, and or tentative weekly starting rosters if they needed help.

I'm stuck @ #2 RB and #3 WR. Here is who I have starting in week one.

QB - Garrard @ Tenn
RB - Barber @ Cleveland
Portis @ NYG, TJones @ Miami, Selvin Young @ Oakland
WR - Colston v. TB
WR - Cotchery @ Miami
Bryant Johnson v. Zona, Hackett @ SD, Porter @ Tenn, Galloway @ NO
TE - Lee v. Minny
K - Jeff Reed v. Houston
JAX D @ Tenn.

Any help/guidance for my second RB and third WR would be appreciated.

Our information has yet to be posted on Yahoo! But, when it is I will be able to let you guys know some of the better FA WRs.
[Reply]

Originally Posted by CJizzles:
Then that's all you should have said.

.5 points per completion/reception

Who do you roll with? My WRs are thin because Colston went down.

Garrard v Buffalo, or Delhomme v. Chi?

I'm leaning towards DG.

Pick 3 -
Cotchery v NE
Galloway v Atl
Bryant Johnson @ Sea
Hackett v Chi
Mason @ Houston

Some FAs to ponder: Reggie Brown, Porter, Darrell Jackson, Gaffney, Kevin Walter, Patten (who could possibly be a could P/U), Toomer.

I'd go with Cotchery, Johnson, and Kevin Walter for your 3 WR slots.

As for QB, that's a pretty tough call. I don't really like either matchup. I think its a toss-up and I wouldn't rely on anyone here to tell you one way or the other.
[Reply]

Originally Posted by noa:
Yeah, both flex positions. Should have mentioned that. No points per reception.

Patten for sure, I think. I'm not sold on either of the RBs. Evans and Walter is a true toss up given the matchups. I'd go 2 WR either way.
[Reply]

Originally Posted by CJizzles:
I decided to drop Hackett and I picked up David Patten.

Cotchery, Patten, and Johnson would be the three WR I'd run out. I like Delhomme; he did fine last week against a decent secondary.
[Reply]

Originally Posted by CJizzles:
So, what do I exactly need to do to get someone to answer my questions?

Cotch, Gall, and then...you're in a spot...probably Patten.
[Reply]

Originally Posted by Bill Lundberg:
McNabb vs. Dallas
or
Warner vs. Miami

McNabb. Going to be a high-scoring game.

At this point, he's an every-week start.
[Reply]

Originally Posted by Bill Lundberg:
McNabb vs. Dallas
or
Warner vs. Miami

McNabb. I think that's going to be a fun game to watch - even though I hate both teams. Should be a lot of points scored.
[Reply]

Originally Posted by RJ:
A couple of more....

Garrard v Bills

or

Schaub v Ravens

and

Michael Turner @ Bucs

or

Matt Forte @ Panthers

The Texas-Ravens game is potentially off due to Ike damage, so it's Garrard by default. Forte's a little nicked, so I'd go with Turner. Bush/Thomas really gashed the Bucs D lasst week.
[Reply]

Current WRs

Roy Williams vs GB
Anquan Boldin vs Miami
Lee Evans @ Jacksonville

(I have Bryant Johnson @ Seattle and Joey Galloway versus Atlanta on the bench... and even though Galloway was a nice surprise last year, I'm not really thinking about starting either of them)

So, the question is... should I pick up David Patten (Colston is out 4-6 weeks) and play him this week @Washington, and who does he replace?

I'm leaning towards replacing Evans, but he had 100+ yards against Seattle last week... probably the luck of the draw on this one, but I'll probably pick him up regardless.
[Reply]

Originally Posted by noa:
I would go with Marshall and Holmes, but it is tough to bench Andre Johnson.

Thanks. I guess I really don't have a choice at this point with Ike doin' its thing.

I think Marshall is going to come out and make a statement.
[Reply]

Since my RBs are pathetic to begin with having Willis' and the Ravens game postponed may cost me.

Currently, I've got Selvin Young against Sandy-Eggo.

I need one more of the three:

Tim Hightower @ Miami
Kolby Smith v. Jokeland
Rudi Johnson v. GB

I'm leaning more towards Hightower - and I've no idea why.
[Reply]

I have a bit of an issue I have 3 very capable RB's and only 2 starting spots....

Marion Barber, Michael Turner, Willie Parker....

What do you guys say?
[Reply]