ChiefsPlanet Mobile
View Poll Results: Grade Mahomes' first half performance
A+ 5 2.94%
A 10 5.88%
A- 13 7.65%
B+ 23 13.53%
B 49 28.82%
B- 34 20.00%
C+ 10 5.88%
C 9 5.29%
C- 6 3.53%
D+ 0 0%
D 3 1.76%
D- 0 0%
F 1 0.59%
I'M AN ALEX SMITH FANBOY PILLOWBITER 2 1.18%
GAZ 5 2.94%
Voters: 170. You may not vote on this poll
Page 5 of 9
< 12345 6789 >
Nzoner's Game Room>Grade Mahomes' first half performance
TLO 06:27 PM 08-17-2018
Poll
[Reply]
Rain Man 10:25 PM 08-17-2018
70 yards in the air.
[Reply]
Shaid 10:27 PM 08-17-2018
Originally Posted by Detoxing:
I agree.

Ugly or not, your QB is giving you a chance. Watkins has to do better than that. It was a poor game for him in general. But he was brought on board to win those jump ball battles. He has to make that play.
Yeah, he slowed down or he'd have at least been in position to defend the int. Still shouldn't have ever been thrown.
[Reply]
ModSocks 10:29 PM 08-17-2018
Originally Posted by Shaid:
YStill shouldn't have ever been thrown.
Fuck that. I say throw it, but throw it better.
[Reply]
Shaid 10:29 PM 08-17-2018
Originally Posted by Rain Man:
70 yards in the air.
That was fantastic to see and why you feel like you always have a chance with Mahomes and Hill in there.
[Reply]
staylor26 10:29 PM 08-17-2018
Originally Posted by -King-:
Watkins got open on the near pick. He did his job. Mahomes should have just got his body around so he wouldn't need to throw across his body.

And the pick wasn't anyone's fault but Mahomes. It was just terrible from the snap. Everybody on the falcons team knew where the ball was going and the throw made it even worse.
Posted via Mobile Device
No he didn’t. Even Reid said he needs to go to the ball instead of standing still.

It was still a poor decision though.
[Reply]
007 10:58 PM 08-17-2018
Eh, you really have to grade the entire team. To be honest, throw out the 70 yard bomb and Mahomes was not impressive. I'm fine with that because I expect "rookie" like issues with him this year.

The starters, however, get a D+ from me.
[Reply]
Tribal Warfare 11:06 PM 08-17-2018
Originally Posted by 007:
Eh, you really have to grade the entire team. To be honest, throw out the 70 yard bomb and Mahomes was not impressive. I'm fine with that because I expect "rookie" like issues with him this year.

The starters, however, get a D+ from me.
That's the great thing about PMII The long range capability will always factor in.

Welcome to the world of a Franchise Gunslinger.
[Reply]
CasselGotPeedOn 11:12 PM 08-17-2018
Originally Posted by 007:
Eh, you really have to grade the entire team. To be honest, throw out the 70 yard bomb and Mahomes was not impressive. I'm fine with that because I expect "rookie" like issues with him this year.

The starters, however, get a D+ from me.
Why would you do that?
[Reply]
Chiefs=Champions 11:24 PM 08-17-2018
I'd put his game at about b+. That pick wasnt great, but you gotta think he just wanted to try and get watkins involved. All you need to do there is hold the safety with your eyes. Hes normally good at that so im not concerned. Everything else was perfect. He's such a weapon if you give him time. The throws to Kelce were also pin point accurate. I think when you get Hunt involved more in the regular season its gonna be almost impossible for defenses to hold us at every level. Pat can make throws that maybe 3 other guys in the league can make. It opens up the entire field. Something we havent had... maybe ever.
[Reply]
New World Order 11:25 PM 08-17-2018
Mahomes started 6-6 and would have been 7-7 with a td if it wasn't for that stupid lineup penalty.

He made one mistake. Other than that he looked pretty damn good.
[Reply]
007 11:40 PM 08-17-2018
Originally Posted by CasselGotPeedOn:
Why would you do that?
ONe play doesn't negate the entire body of work. It was really the only good moment of the half.
[Reply]
Chiefs=Champions 12:16 AM 08-18-2018
Originally Posted by New World Order:
Mahomes started 6-6 and would have been 7-7 with a td if it wasn't for that stupid lineup penalty.

He made one mistake. Other than that he looked pretty damn good.
Exactly.

I think some people view ints and catastrophic cause they were for Smith and frankly didnt happen very often cause he didnt take chances. Bad with the good.
[Reply]
Rasputin 12:17 AM 08-18-2018
Originally Posted by 007:
Eh, you really have to grade the entire team. To be honest, throw out the 70 yard bomb and Mahomes was not impressive. I'm fine with that because I expect "rookie" like issues with him this year.

The starters, however, get a D+ from me.

He was 6/6 on a drive that he threw a TD but called back for illegal alignment or some bullshit but he was money on that drive and that throw to Kelce for a first down how can you not be impressed?
[Reply]
Chiefs=Champions 12:17 AM 08-18-2018
Originally Posted by 007:
ONe play doesn't negate the entire body of work. It was really the only good moment of the half.
No it wasnt. He went 6/6 and had a touchdown that was wiped off. Those moments weren't good in your book? Or are 70 yard touchdowns all you look for?
[Reply]
JakeLV 01:33 AM 08-18-2018
Fucking hell. It’s preseason. Dude threw a pass 1% of NFL caliber QBs could have thrown. Let’s wait for the actual season before we start making decisions
[Reply]
Page 5 of 9
< 12345 6789 >
Up