Yes, first ballot. 30 17.54%

Yes, but it will take a while. 65 38.01%

Yes, but he absolutely should not. 52 30.41%

No, but he should. 1 0.58%

No, and fuck no. 22 12.87%

Kurt sucks. 1 0.58%

Absolutely does not deserve to get in.
[Reply]

2 rings, and the right last name. 1st ballot.
[Reply]

I agree, but I don't like it. He shouldn't get in.
[Reply]

He will get in. Taking 2 of the 9 superbowls the Patriots dynasty went to, one against an undefeated team will get him in.

Otherwise, he was fairly unremarkable. Finished .500 record or thereabout I believe.
[Reply]

Eli Manning won two SBs on the luckiest fucking luck anyone has ever had.

Shit, Trent Dilfer won a Super Bowl, and so did Brad Johnson. Should they be in?
[Reply]

He's definitely getting in.
[Reply]

He will be one of the absolute worst inductees ever. Hes been to 4 pro bowls, 0 All Pros, 0 MVP votes(thats right not even a single vote, the only stat he's lead the league im is INTs and that's 3 times. Hes average as fuck.
[Reply]

I think Eli Manning was a better QB than Aikman. Eli deserves to be in the HOF more than Aikman too. Aikman played with a HOF RB, HOF WR, and HOF offensive linemen, and his numbers at face value are garbage. But he just happened to be under center when the Cowboys won 3 rings.

But winning multiple SB rings, whether you led the team, or just happened to be the game manager at QB when the team won, is a ticket to the HOF, even if it takes a while.

I honestly wouldn't vote for either to be in the HOF.

Sent from my GM1915 using Tapatalk
[Reply]

He’s Top 10 all time in passing yards and passing TDs. He has two SB rings and was MVP of both games. He led his team to a SB win over the previously unbeaten Patriots. He will get in and I would be shocked if it wasn’t first ballot.
[Reply]

Absolutely this. Can you imagine the world if the Patriots had won 2 more Super Bowls?
[Reply]

I’m assuming you’re referencing the Tyree catch? Go back and watch Eli on that play. His ability to avoid being sacked is an oft forgotten part of that play.
[Reply]

All that...
[Reply]

He'll get in. I have no doubts about that. And it's all because of the Superbowl wins. Even though he wasn't the reason that they won. It was that defense. Yeah, I know. He was Superbowl MVP. But that was a crock of shit and everyone knows it. He was nothing more than a game manager carried by the defense both times. I couldn't believe that he was actually named MVP.
[Reply]

Sounds like Troy Aikman.
[Reply]

Led his team is a stretch. You know that he was carried by the defense. Biggest crock of shit MVP ever.
[Reply]