Originally Posted by PAChiefsGuy:
Well you are a moron so that does explain why you'd put a QB in HOF for 'beating' the Pats when you consistently screamed when Alex Smith was here how winning is a 'team accomplishment'.
Typical flip flop from Pablo The Duck.
Eli doesn't deserve to get in. He's an average QB who helped win Giants two SBs with some clutch plays. But those Giants teams mainly won due to probably the best dline the NFL has ever seen.
Hey, Alice didn't win shit when he was here. And he never will. Go chug his jizz on a Skins board you massive queer. [Reply]
Originally Posted by Easy 6:
Without Eli the Patriots would have EIGHT championships
He should go in for that reason alone IMO
And his brother's teams knocked them out of three AFC championship games. Brady made it to 12 championship games during an era where the NFL is set up to create parity. Total b.s. Cheating cunts. [Reply]
Originally Posted by Mennonite:
And his brother's teams knocked them out of three AFC championship games. Brady made it to 12 championship games during an era where the NFL is set up to create parity. Total b.s. Cheating ****s.
Yeah, Peyton was 3-1 vs Brady in the AFCCG and Eli was 2-0 vs Brady in the SB. Crazy. Mannings ended Brady's season 5 of 6 times they matched up. [Reply]
Originally Posted by Mile High Mania:
So, explain that... would love to hear the argument.
I've already gone on record to say that Eli, Ben, Rivers, Ryan and ultimatlely Stafford if he plays another 3-4 years will get in on stats/longevity alone. But, curious to hear the Ryan is greater than Eli bullet points.
10 points better career QB rating, far few interceptions. Quick look at the raw stats. [Reply]
He will make it into the Hall of Favorites. New York has too much power. The strength of the Giants was always the defense. Eli never impressed me as being all that smart and due to a dropped interception on the play before, the helmet catch occurred. As others have said, he is Rivers with a couple of rings. Put Eli in the AFC West and he does nothing except get smashed. [Reply]
Originally Posted by FringeNC:
10 points better career QB rating, far few interceptions. Quick look at the raw stats.
Well, 234 vs 189 games started... overall, Ryan has a 2.2% INT ratio compard to 3.0% for Eli.
For example, Favre was 3.3% and his QB rating was only 2 greater than Eli. Marino was also at a 3% INT ratio with an 86 QB rating. Not suggesting either QB is like Favre or Marino. Just seems like weird stats to compare.
I dunno that those two stats do much for me to differentiate between Eli and Ryan. [Reply]
