Originally Posted by Pitt Gorilla:
Kneeling, in no way, disrespects the flag or the anthem. Even you understand that.
The presentation of the flag and the performance of the anthem is, whatever you think of the worth or merit, intended as a moment of unified recognition of commonality. It's purpose is to say 'hey, take a pause and reflect on the good things we share.' If you kneel, or turn your back, or stay away, or ride an exercycle, purposefully to distinguish yourself from that moment, it indicates, whether intentional or not, that you wish to disassociate.
If that's truly not what you intend to do, you do something different.
If that's what you intend to do, but you feel you have good reason, state your reason.
If people find your conduct disrepectful, that's their right.
Remember when we have other conversations about how people should or shouldn't emotionally react to symbols or statements, and so many of you PASSIONATELY argued just that, that it is the right of the individual to respond to the symbol or statement or act, as their consciences dictates?
And again reiterating yet another thing I'm sure I've already said, just because I explain things so people can understand ALL sides, which is what we're supposed to be doing, doesn't mean I advocate, or certainly not that I'm passionate about, those specific things myself.
I've done enough eye-rolling and moving on at other stuff, the protest stuff doesn't really bother me one way or another.
But you lot are trying to police the individual responses of everyone, based on your particular perspective, which seems the opposite of empathy. [Reply]
Originally Posted by Baby Lee:
The presentation of the flag and the performance of the anthem is, whatever you think of the worth or merit, intended as a moment of unified recognition of commonality. It's purpose is to say 'hey, take a pause and reflect on the good things we share.' If you kneel, or turn your back, or stay away, or ride an exercycle, purposefully to distinguish yourself from that moment, it indicates, whether intentional or not, that you wish to disassociate.
If that's truly not what you intend to do, you do something different.
If that's what you intend to do, but you feel you have good reason, state your reason.
If people find your conduct disrepectful, that's their right.
Remember when we have other conversations about how people should or shouldn't emotionally react to symbols or statements, and so many of you PASSIONATELY argued just that, that it is the right of the individual to respond to the symbol or statement or act, as their consciences dictates?
And again reiterating yet another thing I'm sure I've already said, just because I explain things so people can understand ALL sides, which is what we're supposed to be doing, doesn't mean I advocate, or certainly not that I'm passionate about, those specific things myself.
I've done enough eye-rolling and moving on at other stuff, the protest stuff doesn't really bother me one way or another.
But you lot are trying to police the individual responses of everyone, based on your particular perspective, which seems the opposite of empathy.
If they had meant to disrespect the flag or the anthem, wouldn't they have said just that? In all of the times I've heard or read players explaining their kneeling, I've not seen many/any? suggest they wish to disrespect the flag or the anthem. So, clearly, that is not their intention. I'd not suggest that someone else won't choose to perceive it that way (as is their right), but it certainly doesn't appear to be their intent. [Reply]
Originally Posted by Pitt Gorilla:
If they had meant to disrespect the flag or the anthem, wouldn't they have said just that? In all of the times I've heard or read players explaining their kneeling, I've not seen many/any? suggest they wish to disrespect the flag or the anthem. So, clearly, that is not their intention. I'd not suggest that someone else won't choose to perceive it that way (as is their right), but it certainly doesn't appear to be their intent.
I'm not going to dig up the exact quote, but as for Kaep he said something very close to 'what they're doing with that flag and anthem, just wasn't something I could participate in.'
I'm not saying personally that the descriptor I would use is 'disrespectful,' but;
Originally Posted by Pitt Gorilla:
OR say whatever you like, but don't be surprised when people choose to react to it however they like.
Originally Posted by Baby Lee:
I'm not going to dig up the exact quote, but as for Kaep he said something very close to 'what they're doing with that flag and anthem, just wasn't something I could participate in.'
I'm not saying personally that the descriptor I would use is 'disrespectful,l but;
I suppose if we define "disrespect" as "non-participation", then, yes, he's clearly being disrespectful.
I'm guessing the totality of things we disrespect through non-participation is close to innumerable. [Reply]
Originally Posted by Baby Lee:
The presentation of the flag and the performance of the anthem is, whatever you think of the worth or merit, intended as a moment of unified recognition of commonality. It's purpose is to say 'hey, take a pause and reflect on the good things we share.' If you kneel, or turn your back, or stay away, or ride an exercycle, purposefully to distinguish yourself from that moment, it indicates, whether intentional or not, that you wish to disassociate.
If that's truly not what you intend to do, you do something different.
If that's what you intend to do, but you feel you have good reason, state your reason.
If people find your conduct disrepectful, that's their right.
Remember when we have other conversations about how people should or shouldn't emotionally react to symbols or statements, and so many of you PASSIONATELY argued just that, that it is the right of the individual to respond to the symbol or statement or act, as their consciences dictates?
And again reiterating yet another thing I'm sure I've already said, just because I explain things so people can understand ALL sides, which is what we're supposed to be doing, doesn't mean I advocate, or certainly not that I'm passionate about, those specific things myself.
I've done enough eye-rolling and moving on at other stuff, the protest stuff doesn't really bother me one way or another.
But you lot are trying to police the individual responses of everyone, based on your particular perspective, which seems the opposite of empathy.
You really like hearing yourself speak irl don’t you? [Reply]
Originally Posted by Baby Lee:
This from the guy who welched on a pledge to leave, then went around the internet recruiting minions to brigade the forum.
All you want is war. If someone says something reasonable, you reinterpret it for something inflammatory or confrontational.
You personify so much that is wrong with the world.
Lol yet again you don't even try to address the point - just stick to the personal attacks. [Reply]