After he'd lived his life, he might have "warped" back to the present. They showed earlier in the movie that they could warp between times without going back to the big crazy machine.
[Reply]

This element of assumption time travel is what bothers me. If killing "past" Nebula exists in another timeline then how does Cap exist in the same manner. I'm cool with Cap staying away from the action to live his life with Peggy to be a stay at home husband but the Nebula deviation is the paradox that kills the mingling between Old Cap and Falcon if he is descending from a different reality.
[Reply]

Disagree. They didn't just reverse the snap they brought all that we're snapped to present time. 5 years later. Technically all of spideys friends graduated. This was Tony's wish. He wanted his daughter. Reversing the snap would have erased them all.

Also disagree on merged minds. If that were the case gamorra would have had memories.
[Reply]

Alternate timeline with time travel.
[Reply]

Well, the fact that Thanos and his whole crew died before Infinity War is probably a bigger problem. To me everything points to the past timelines actually being alternate universes except old Cap showing up at the end.

On the other hand this could be early setup for the next thing. Something like Infinity/Secret Wars arc, where time travel paradoxes are causing the multiverse to collapse in on itself. Also the whole thing the Ancient Ones goes into about how removing one Infinity Stone fucks up the timeline, and they now live in a universe with zero Infinity stones.
[Reply]

Few things:

-why didn’t they use the time stone to bring Tony back to life? Thanos did that with Vision in IW
-Tony gets a big funeral but Natasha doesn’t? Damn
-is Loki still alive in an alternate timeline?
[Reply]

The SJW shit was so cringe worthy and obvious. Thor was the best. Made the whole movie. Everything else went exactly as the majority thought it would. Deaths and Staying in the past. Solid ending to an epic phase of a monstrous franchise. IDK if I care enough to watch anything after GotG and Spidey in the future.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
[Reply]

it was only briefly mentioned above, but the one question i have is where did loki end up? loved the interaction with the past and all of the cameos.

proud of myself for not having to get up during the movie after drinking a big gulp. :-)
[Reply]

How does the old Cap stuff work in the timeline?
[Reply]

You mean like him being an old man or the older cap movies?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
[Reply]

A combination of both. How did the revelation fit him being in the Avengers and the timeline?
[Reply]

Him living in the universe's past is his present/future. Younger him still did everything he did in his past. So nothing is changed that way.

What may be changed is Peggy Carter's present. They may have retconned her entire origin with SHIELD. Or not, because maybe she still does the exact same thing


And who knows, he may have done some heroic things on his own between the 50s and his reappearance. Just...hidden.

I'm not gonna spend too much time thinking about it. It was a nice coda after the sadness of the funeral.
[Reply]

What about his actions with the Avengers? If he was never frozen, then how does that work?
[Reply]

He was frozen. Everything that we've seen in the movies happened. Younger him is still frozen in the ice.
[Reply]

OK. Thanks.
[Reply]