The whole point of Mt. Rushmore though is no one ever gets knocked off. So let's just say Mahomes is carving it right now for Brett, Watson, Dawson, and Thomas. But there will be a 5th place for him when he's done playing.
[Reply]

What's the St. Louis Mt. Rushmore? Pooholes, Ozzie, Brett Hull, Eric Dickerson?

Lame - like most things St. Louis.
[Reply]

Patrick Mahomes
Lenny Dawson
Bret Saberhagen
George Bret
[Reply]

Buck O'Neil is a great choice.
[Reply]

Tamarick Vanover
Bam Morris
Jovian Belcher
Kareem Hunt
[Reply]

I'm not a baseball expert, but I'm pretty sure Stan Musial is the greatest Cardinals player.

Eric Dickerson never played for St. Louis.
[Reply]

When you look at something like Mt. Rushmore, you should have only the cream of the crop, those that excelled year after year. In my opinion, that would be Buck O'Neill, Lenny the Cool, Tommy Watson, and George Brett. You could make arguments for a lot of other people, but those guys are Kansas City. Before anyone cries about leaving PMII off the list, I'm reserving a blank spot for him.
[Reply]

Musial, Pujols, Warner, Gibson, Hull.

HM: Ryan O’Reilly, Marshall Faulk, Isaac Bruce, Dan Dierdorf, Roger Werhli, Bob Gibson, Lou Brock, Yogi Berra, Max Scherzer, Torry Holt, Steven Jackson, Orlando Pace, Al MacCinnis.

And go **** your self.
[Reply]

Max Scherzer?
[Reply]

That list is about as impressive as St. Louis BBQ.
[Reply]

He’s from the St. Louis area, as well as Ryan Howard.

I’d take the history of all St. Louis sports teams against every single team from LA-including the Rams history-short of the Lakers.
[Reply]

As previously mentioned, Dickerson never played in St. Louis. Warner, Holt, Bruce, and Faulk would be better Rams options.

Lots of Cardinals greats. They have been around so much longer than the Royals, there would be so many to choose from. Musial, Hornsby, Gibson, Brock, Pujols, Ozzie, Molina, Boyer, Mize, Edmonds, etc.
[Reply]

That's kind of a silly reason to put him on a list like this. If we're doing that, move Pujols to the Kansas City list.
[Reply]

Depends on how you view it.

Kobe’s arguably one of the greatest athletes to come from Philly but his career went elsewhere. I wonder if Philly sports fans would put him up there?

If it’s strictly career based in the city, then sure, he shouldn’t be included.

Now for KC:
Brett
Watson
Mahomes
Dawson
Thomas
[Reply]

That's like saying Kansas Citians would take KC's sports history over St Louis as long as you don't include the Cardinals. :-)
[Reply]