ChiefsPlanet Mobile
View Poll Results: Grade Mahomes' first half performance
A+ 5 2.94%
A 10 5.88%
A- 13 7.65%
B+ 23 13.53%
B 49 28.82%
B- 34 20.00%
C+ 10 5.88%
C 9 5.29%
C- 6 3.53%
D+ 0 0%
D 3 1.76%
D- 0 0%
F 1 0.59%
I'M AN ALEX SMITH FANBOY PILLOWBITER 2 1.18%
GAZ 5 2.94%
Voters: 170. You may not vote on this poll
Page 2 of 9
< 12 3456 > Last »
Nzoner's Game Room>Grade Mahomes' first half performance
TLO 06:27 PM 08-17-2018
Poll
[Reply]
TLO 06:56 PM 08-17-2018
Originally Posted by CrowbarMan:
Was Atlanta's starting D on the field at the end of the half?

If not his grade should be a D or F for the terrible throws. Most teams won't give up a bomb like that with 28 seconds to go in the half. You know it's coming.
Looked like the Falcons knew it was coming. There were 3 guys back there.

They still couldn't stop it.
[Reply]
Baby Lee 07:14 PM 08-17-2018
Originally Posted by TLO:
Looked like the Falcons knew it was coming. There were 3 guys back there.

They still couldn't stop it.
Really tough to figure what went into that.

They devoted 3 down the middle deep to Reek, but they let him behind all of them. And it's not like Reek flat-out burned past them, he went into cruise and even stuttered a bit waiting for the ball to come down.

One might think they didn't think Mahomes could throw that far or something, but it's hard to believe all three 2nd teamers had such a specific limitation in their heads regarding coverage [ie, a conscious decision to cover Reek close for 65 yards, . . but not 70].
But then, they did seem pretty blase about him strolling free 5 yards behind them.
[Reply]
MTG#10 07:14 PM 08-17-2018
B. He's going to be special with a season starting under his belt.
[Reply]
Otter 07:19 PM 08-17-2018
B

3rd NFL start and the coaches came out trying to establish the run. Threw a bad INT, almost 2, and 72 yard bomb for a strike that landed right in the bread basket to Hill and another the Kelce. He looks comfortable and confident out there and I for one am excited for the kid and see no reason for him to fail.

32 teams in the NFL. 3 QBs on each team.

How many of those 96 QBs have the arm strength to make that throw? 10%? I'm guessing. One of those 10% is the Chiefs QB and he's barely old enough to drink legally, has the future and has all the potential in the world.
[Reply]
Easy 6 07:25 PM 08-17-2018
The 6-6 start, the money throw to Kelce on 3rd and long, the statline of 8-12 for 138 and 1-1... and last but not least, the Madden play come to life 70 yard bomb

All equals a solid A all day in my book, we went into the half on a high and only down 4... Pat was steady and flashy

Also, the pick looked like Robinsons fault to me, he was half speed and not even looking for the ball
[Reply]
RunKC 07:27 PM 08-17-2018
B

He had 2 poor throws. The pick and the end zone pass. Everything else was good
[Reply]
Coogs 07:29 PM 08-17-2018
Originally Posted by Easy 6:
The 6-6 start, the money throw to Kelce on 3rd and long, the statline of 8-12 for 138 and 1-1... and last but not least, the Madden play come to life 70 yard bomb

All equals a solid A all day in my book, we went into the half on a high and only down 4... Pat was steady and flashy

Also, the pick looked like Robinsons fault to me, he was half speed and not even looking for the ball
14 is Watkins. Robinson switched to 11 from being 14 last season.
[Reply]
Coogs 07:30 PM 08-17-2018
Originally Posted by RunKC:
B

He had 2 poor throws. The pick and the end zone pass. Everything else was good
Watkins didn't help him on either one.
[Reply]
Easy 6 07:35 PM 08-17-2018
Originally Posted by Coogs:
14 is Watkins. Robinson switched to 11 from being 14 last season.
Aha, well... anyway
[Reply]
MMXcalibur 07:40 PM 08-17-2018
I gave him an A- under the thinking that he'll learn from that poor interception going forward.
[Reply]
Coogs 07:42 PM 08-17-2018
Originally Posted by Easy 6:
Aha, well... anyway
I know what you were saying, and I agree.
[Reply]
Coogs 07:42 PM 08-17-2018
Originally Posted by KCtotheSB:
I gave him an A- under the thinking that he'll learn from that poor interception going forward.
:-)

He should have had 2 TD's vs 1 INT if it were not for a very iffy flag by the official. 2:1 TD to INT ratio is very good in the NFL.
[Reply]
Marcellus 07:43 PM 08-17-2018
Gave him a B but here is the thing-

The silly INTs not seeing the safety will get way more rare.

The arm talent 1st downs like the one to Kelce early and ridiculous TD throws won't.

Boner fuel.
[Reply]
Sassy Squatch 07:47 PM 08-17-2018
That throw to Watkins that was picked was so horrendous it docked him a full grade to a C. He did literally everything wrong on that throw. Fix that and he'll be just fine.
[Reply]
dirk digler 07:49 PM 08-17-2018
He didn’t get hurt
Threw a 70 yd TD bomb
Threw a couple of shitty passes to learn from

So it is an A for me
[Reply]
Page 2 of 9
< 12 3456 > Last »
Up