Football Kyler Murray vs Garner Minshew - Page 3

Try....Gardner

This from last season.

Murray

Comp %...69.0
yards...4361
TD/INT...42-7

Minshew

70.7
4779
38-9

I can see a situation similiar to Bledsoe/Brady, Romo/Prescott here. I saw 6/7 WSU games last season, trust me Minshew can play. I have no problems seeing him taking Foles job away, just think Matt Flynn/Russell Wilson.

I also see him out playing Murray.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JhRFWO6Mfb0
[Reply]

The way I judge a rookie QB is very simple. Does he look nervous? Is he making plays downfield? Is he accurate? I'd say he did very well in all of these areas. I certainly didn't expect as much poise out of him as he showed.

I don't know if he'll be a starter in this league, but he certainly has a future as a
GOOD backup in this league, which he already is.
[Reply]

Yeah but which one is black and can hand off to a white RB?
[Reply]

Originally Posted by Three7s:
The way I judge a rookie QB is very simple. Does he look nervous? Is he making plays downfield? Is he accurate? I'd say he did very well in all of these areas. I certainly didn't expect as much poise out of him as he showed.

I don't know if he'll be a starter in this league, but he certainly has a future as a
GOOD backup in this league, which he already is.

I think you pretty much nailed it. Decision making and protecting the ball for a young guy very important.

I saw Rodgers at Cal, Luck at Stanford, Darnold/Rosen, they had nothing on Minshew at the NCAA level.
[Reply]

Originally Posted by Jewish Rabbi:
Yeah but which one is black and can hand off to a white RB?

Little man, did you really post this stupidity?

Internet jukeboxes
**** em. And **** the Bosniaks that play 20 ****ing minute long techno songs.

Which got....0...replies.

Dude, grow the **** up, ok guy?
[Reply]

If Mindhew fails it looks to me like his arm won’t be good enough or he won’t stay healthy. Or of course coaching can ruin him.

It looked like he had it between the ears last week.
[Reply]

Minshew is 2 foot taller.
[Reply]

Originally Posted by Ubeja Vontell:
Little man, did you really post this stupidity?

Internet jukeboxes
**** em. And **** the Bosniaks that play 20 ****ing minute long techno songs.

Which got....0...replies.

Dude, grow the **** up, ok guy?

Incredibly healthy brain
[Reply]

Originally Posted by Jewish Rabbi:
Yeah but which one is black and can hand off to a white RB?

Or why not the more obvious Baker Mayfield comps.

Cooper Barrett has a race preoccupation.
[Reply]

Originally Posted by Ubeja Vontell:
There is a blues cat that goes with...WillieB

Anyway....

Let's try this my man....

In his rookie season Nick Foles started 6 games and put up these numbers.

Comp% 60.9
Yards 1699
TD/INT 6/5

I have no doubts of any kind that Minshew does far better than that AND...out plays Murray.

BWillie is wrong a lot, so you may be right.
[Reply]

Originally Posted by Bump:
we have a tradition of facing a QB that's never played before and kicking off their career by making them look good. Then they get a starting job and suck.

Yup.
[Reply]

Did you guys know that one of these QBs is black, and one of them is white?

*waits for this dweeb to search my thread history to find one with a small number of replies, with his trademark punchline "ok guy?" at the end*
[Reply]

Originally Posted by Mama Hip Rockets:
Did you guys know that one of these QBs is black, and one of them is white?

*waits for this dweeb to search my thread history to find one with a small number of replies, with his trademark punchline "ok guy?" at the end*

Remember when you made a drunk thread 8 years ago, dumbshit? You’re one to talk, okay guy?

I don’t even know who this Cooper guy is, but can he google random track statistics like I can?
[Reply]

should change the title to MINSHAW vs Mahomes :

2019:
Gardner Minshew
88%.... 275 yrds.... 11 yrds per throw..... 2 TDS

Mahomes:
75.8% 378yrds 11.5 per throw 3TDS

[Reply]

Kyler Murray looks like a homunculus.
For that reason, Garden Cashew gets my vote.
[Reply]

Originally Posted by Buehler445:
If Mindhew fails it looks to me like his arm won’t be good enough or he won’t stay healthy. Or of course coaching can ruin him.

It looked like he had it between the ears last week.

There is no doubt about his arm, none.
[Reply]