Originally Posted by RunKC:
The big question we should be asking ourselves is how much disparity is there between the late 1st rd WR’s like McConkey, Franklin and Worthy and guys like Tez Walker?
Bc Tez Walker is a guy with high upside that was a weapon in college and could be really high potential here. He’s not my favorite but he’s undoubtedly a high ceiling player who could win the way DK Metcalf does downfield.
And for the life of me I don’t get the 3rd rd grade for Jalen McMillan. That guy is ****ing good. He’s a football player who knows how to get open. He knows how to vary routes and he knows how to find the open space.
Don’t care that he ran a 4.47. Tank Dell ran a 4.49 and had the same skills and the guy was amazing last year.
I like McMillan but see him as a possible future starter like Marvin Jones. That's a nice find but I want more upside with a 1st or 2nd round pick. [Reply]
Originally Posted by staylor26:
"Neither is a clear round 1 player"
Yea, basically anybody you take at 32 won't be you butt****ing moron.
You realize there are significantly less than 32 1st round grades in every draft, correct?
Pretty sure MHJ, Nabers and Odunze are the only unanimous WR’s with first rd grades. I’d say probably half or more of teams have BTJ as a first rd prospect and maybe a handful of teams grade Mitchell as a 1st rd talent.
There’s usually 15-18 players in a draft with first rd grades so the odds aren’t high more than 4 WR’s are graded that high. [Reply]
Originally Posted by RunKC:
Pretty sure MHJ, Nabers and Odunze are the only unanimous WR’s with first rd grades. I’d say probably half or more of teams have BTJ as a first rd prospect and maybe a handful of teams grade Mitchell as a 1st rd talent.
There’s usually 15-18 players in a draft with first rd grades so the odds aren’t high more than 4 WR’s are graded that high.
Exactly, so considering nobody has ever thought Worthy and Franklin are out of our range, nobody would say it's "crazy" to give them a 2nd round grade. [Reply]
Originally Posted by staylor26:
Exactly, so considering nobody has ever thought Worthy and Franklin are out of our range, nobody would say it's "crazy" to give them a 2nd round grade.
You argued with me over and over and over when I said I thought they were 2nd round prospects.
Originally Posted by RunKC:
Pretty sure MHJ, Nabers and Odunze are the only unanimous WR’s with first rd grades. I’d say probably half or more of teams have BTJ as a first rd prospect and maybe a handful of teams grade Mitchell as a 1st rd talent.
There’s usually 15-18 players in a draft with first rd grades so the odds aren’t high more than 4 WR’s are graded that high.
There is no way that half the teams have BTJ as a 2nd round prospect.
Your contention that only a few teams have Adonai as a 1st rounder is based on what exactly? [Reply]
[QUOTE=staylor26;17424164]Wow, very bold of you Captain Hindsight.
Rice would easily be a 1st in a redraft, and Reed would be a high 2nd. So you mean to tell me you'll take the proven commodity over the mystery box at 32? Shocker!
Exactly what ****ing point do you think you're making here reerun?[/QUOTE]
Look at how mad he got when I mentioned that the guys being promoted for a 1st round pick for the Chiefs were not as good as guys that went in the 2nd last year.
Originally Posted by staylor26: Wow, very bold of you Captain Hindsight.
Rice would easily be a 1st in a redraft, and Reed would be a high 2nd. So you mean to tell me you'll take the proven commodity over the mystery box at 32? Shocker!
Exactly what ****ing point do you think you're making here reerun?
The actual fucking argument.
Still waiting for this:
Originally Posted by staylor26:
Show me where I was arguing specifically against a 2nd round grade or :-)
No, you just don't know how to quote a post correctly so I was trying to fix it in an edit before finishing my post. You had your chance to show me where I, or anybody else, argued against Franklin having a 2nd round grade, and all you found was me telling you were making an irrelevant point playing Captain Hindsight.
Thanks for proving for the millionth time that you're a fucking liar. Not a single person told you you were "crazy" for having Franklin in the 2nd round.
I've been here since 2007 and never once put somebody on ignore. You're about to be the first. [Reply]
Originally Posted by staylor26:
No, you just don't know how to quote a post correctly so I was trying to fix it in an edit before finishing my post. You had your chance to show me where I, or anybody else, argued against Franklin having a 2nd round grade, and all you found was me telling you were making an irrelevant point playing Captain Hindsight.
Thanks for proving for the millionth time that you're a ****ing liar. Not a single person told you you were "crazy" for having Franklin in the 2nd round.
I've been here since 2007 and never once put somebody on ignore. You're about to be the first.
Go ahead snowflake. You're more emotional than most chicks. [Reply]
Projecting The Top Wide Receivers In The 2024 Class
PLAYER SCHOOL PLAYMAKER SCORE PLAYMAKER RATING
Malik Nabers LSU 779 99.3%
Brian Thomas Jr. LSU 750 99.0%
Rome Odunze Washington 693 95.9%
Marvin Harrison Jr. Ohio St. 671 93.4%
Adonai Mitchell Texas 631 86.4%
Xavier Worthy Texas 577 94.5%
Keon Coleman Florida State 514 78.2%
Troy Franklin Oregon 480 83.5%
Devontez Walker North Carolina 447 78.6%
Ladd McConkey Georgia 441 58.2%
Ja'Lynn Polk Washington 438 92.3%
Xavier Legette South Carolina 429 47.1%
Jalen McMillan Washington 409 87.3%
Malachi Corley Western Kentucky 354 74.3%
Jermaine Burton Alabama 304 41.0%
Luke McCaffrey Rice 295 87.0%
Roman Wilson Michigan 292 56.1%
Ainias Smith Texas A&M 286 46.8%
Javon Baker UCF 284 45.2%
Ricky Pearsall Florida 266 21.6%
Jamari Thrash Louisville 250 58.8%
Johnny Wilson Florida State 250 73.7%
Jacob Cowing Arizona 203 69.3%
Brenden Rice USC 191 37.0%
Malik Washington Virginia 164 62.1%
Bub Means Pittsburgh 158 17.6%
Tahj Washington USC 157 39.3%
Lideatrick Griffin Mississippi St. 133 19.0%
Marcus Rosemy-Jacksaint Georgia 124 14.2%
Tayvion Robinson Kentucky 118 22.1%
Anthony Gould Oregon St. 116 53.1%
Cornelius Johnson Michigan 115 14.7%
Jha'Quan Jackson Tulane 91 10.0%
Devaughn Vele Utah 90 53.2%
Jordan Whittington Texas 86 40.2%
Isaiah Williams Illinois 57 31.8%
Xavier Weaver Colorado 31 15.6%
The note on McCaffery is interesting. They’d have him 8th save for his rating by SCOUTS inc. Worthy would rank ahead of Mitchell if not for SCOUTS, too. [Reply]
