Skyy Moore 76 35.68%

Kadarius Toney 133 62.44%

Justyn Ross 4 1.88%

Justin Watson 0 0%

Fuck off with that straw man nonsense.

Most of the board was unhappy when the reports came out that the best coaching staff in the league was looking at him as the teams #1 WR.

Nobody ever thought Toney was “a solid #1” outside of a handful of idiots.
[Reply]

Toney was a lottery ticket acquired mid season via trade from a (currently) shit franchise. Skyy was a deliberate draft pick in his second season.


Skyy's the bigger disappointment.
[Reply]

Toney was the most disappointing to me. If we could just teach the guy to catch instead of playing 'Hot Potato'...
[Reply]

I voted Moore because it seemed he was doing everything right to become a reliable WR, he just didn't have the talent and I have to assume he got massive yips during games.
[Reply]

I thought Toney could be a capable punt returner/gadget receiver. Never believed he would be a WR1 or 2 or could stay healthy long enough to matter in the regular passing game. Did not have high expectation for Ross or Watson.

I did expect Moore to take a couple steps forward. He did not. For a 2nd round pick, he has been disappointing. He just did not seem to be on the same page as Mahomes….then injured.
[Reply]