ChiefsPlanet Mobile
View Poll Results: Alex Smith's Grade Card
Part 1: Grade for the 2017 Season 1 0.72%
A+ 4 2.88%
A 17 12.23%
A- 21 15.11%
B+ 45 32.37%
B 23 16.55%
B- 6 4.32%
C+ 2 1.44%
C 4 2.88%
C- 3 2.16%
D+ 2 1.44%
D 0 0%
D- 0 0%
F 8 5.76%
No grade 0 0%
Part 2: 2017 Performance Relative to Expectations 1 0.72%
Greatly exceeded my expectations 38 27.34%
Slightly exceeded my expectations 76 54.68%
Performed about like I expected 13 9.35%
Performed slightly worse than my expectations 1 0.72%
Performed far short of my expectations 4 2.88%
Part 3: Desired Role for 2018 1 0.72%
Much larger 1 0.72%
Slightly larger 1 0.72%
About the same as 2017 4 2.88%
Slightly smaller 1 0.72%
Much smaller 7 5.04%
Off the team 116 83.45%
Part 4: I think this player’s ability is … 2 1.44%
Ascending 11 7.91%
Stable 87 62.59%
Descending 34 24.46%
Part 5: The minimum I would trade this player for is a mid- … 1 0.72%
-sized bottle of Pibb Extra 11 7.91%
7th round pick 2 1.44%
6th round pick 0 0%
5th round pick 2 1.44%
4th round pick 3 2.16%
3rd round pick 35 25.18%
2nd round pick 69 49.64%
1st round pick 17 12.23%
A pair of 1st round picks 4 2.88%
I would not trade this player 2 1.44%
Part 6: I prefer… 1 0.72%
Great Pyramid 61 43.88%
Great Wall 45 32.37%
Multiple Choice Poll. Voters: 139. You may not vote on this poll
Page 7 of 8
« First < 34567 8 >
Nzoner's Game Room>Chiefs Offseason Planet Evaluation: Alex Smith
Rain Man 07:10 PM 01-18-2018
Even the MVP must get a grade card. Let the world know what you think.

Alex played in 15 games with 15 starts this season (sitting out one game to watch the Ghost of Christmas Future). He completed 341 passes at a 67.5% completion rate, for 4,402 yards and 8.0 yards per attempt. He threw 26 touchdown passes and 5 interceptions. His quarterback rating was 104.7.

Atop that, he ran for 355 yards and 1 TD, at 5.9 yards per rush.
[Reply]
NJChiefsFan 09:02 PM 01-19-2018
Originally Posted by Sandy Vagina:
I don't believe this to be fair... and seems to alleviate everyone else of their blame.. while only focusing the blame on the QB.

( hint: HC clams up after gaining any real lead... again... and team suffers for their arrogance of holding the lead )

Think it over.
I'm not blaming the game on Alex. But when looking specifically at how he himself played this year, the two reminded me of each other. Enough film of the second half of that playoff game for Alex that reminds me of mid-season.

True, like midseason, plenty of blame to go around. This was more evaluating Smith with himself, like the idea of the thread, not trying to single him out.
[Reply]
Sweet Daddy Hate 09:26 PM 01-19-2018
Originally Posted by Sandy Vagina:
Guy makes 100+ mil by age 33... what a silly joke. Imagine the meth, courage, and real love you could have pretended to have with all that, SDH. :-)

( i mean, aside from the internet, lmao )
Maybe he can loan you some money to hire a commercial kitchen power-sprayer to come on by and clean out that fetid gash of yours?

Give 'em a call!

(assuming you aren't on a restraining order already...stupid whore)
[Reply]
Sandy Vagina 09:36 PM 01-19-2018
hahaha.. reign in your triggered gimp, Claynus. He mad.

:-)
[Reply]
Sweet Daddy Hate 12:11 AM 01-20-2018
Originally Posted by Sandy Vagina:
hahaha.. reign in your triggered gimp, Claynus. He mad.

:-)
Kill yourself.

Dumb whore.
[Reply]
007 12:33 AM 01-20-2018
Off the team was the only option you needed
[Reply]
Rasputin 09:48 AM 01-20-2018
1/4


Failed again in the playoffs so he gets an F



I don't really care how good he was in the season he failed in the playoffs when it mattered and no he wasn't all to blame but I think we could have beat the Titans with Patrick Mahomes II starting.
[Reply]
Rausch 09:49 AM 01-20-2018
Originally Posted by KC Tattoo:
1/4


Failed again in the playoffs so he gets an F
Did he fail or did our OC and DC fail?...
[Reply]
Rasputin 09:55 AM 01-20-2018
Originally Posted by Rausch:
Did he fail or did our OC and DC fail?...

I give the coaches F. Alex Smith failed to lead the team to victory, he had the opportunity to win it.
[Reply]
Rausch 10:06 AM 01-20-2018
Originally Posted by KC Tattoo:
I give the coaches F.
I'd say D.

They won the first half but lost the game.

Originally Posted by KC Tattoo:
Alex Smith failed to lead the team to victory, he had the opportunity to win it.
No, he really didn't.

His HC went all tight-butthole in the 2nd half and Kelcee was out. And their best option then was to feed Hunt and we really didn't do that either...
[Reply]
Rasputin 10:28 AM 01-20-2018
Originally Posted by Rausch:
I'd say D.

They won the first half but lost the game.



No, he really didn't.

His HC went all tight-butthole in the 2nd half and Kelcee was out. And their best option then was to feed Hunt and we really didn't do that either...
All the more reason to give the coaches an F they couldn't adjust to the adjustments the the Tits made. They got out coached and out played in the second half.


Losing Kelce was a punch in the dick that is for sure but Mahomes didn't have Kelce or half the starters on offense and he managed to find ways to convert on third downs. Third down is still the Achilles heel in this Alex Smith/Andy Reid WCO.
[Reply]
JENKINSWINS 11:02 AM 01-20-2018
Originally Posted by KC Tattoo:
All the more reason to give the coaches an F they couldn't adjust to the adjustments the the Tits made. They got out coached and out played in the second half.


Losing Kelce was a punch in the dick that is for sure but Mahomes didn't have Kelce or half the starters on offense and he managed to find ways to convert on third downs. Third down is still the Achilles heel in this Alex Smith/Andy Reid WCO.
People keep bringing up that meaningless game. If anything you Mahomosexuals should know that Mahomes has more chemistry with 2nd and 3rd stringers.
[Reply]
Hammock Parties 11:02 AM 01-20-2018
Originally Posted by Sandy Vagina:
hahaha.. reign in your triggered gimp, Claynus. He mad.

:-)
on the contrary, my dear sandra

he must run free like the wild stallion he is, to trample the smith-loving cunts of the world just as alex's playoff frauds were trampled by real contenders

this is his hour

make us proud, sweets

DO WHAT MUST BE DONE, LORD CARLSATAN! DO NOT HESITATE! SHOW NO MERCY.
[Reply]
Rausch 11:11 AM 01-20-2018
Originally Posted by KC Tattoo:
All the more reason to give the coaches an F they couldn't adjust to the adjustments the the Tits made.
They didn't.

I'd argue the offense never did in the 2nd half, all year, until Naggy took over.

Originally Posted by KC Tattoo:
They got out coached and out played in the second half.
True. I have nothing to add.

Originally Posted by KC Tattoo:
Losing Kelce was a punch in the dick that is for sure but Mahomes didn't have Kelce or half the starters on offense and he managed to find ways to convert on third downs.
Our offense and defense performed better on the road, with a rookie QB and no starters on offense, than we did in our home playoff game with all the starters.

You do the math.

Originally Posted by KC Tattoo:
Third down is still the Achilles heel in this Alex Smith/Andy Reid WCO.
Yup...
[Reply]
RealSNR 12:14 PM 01-20-2018
Originally Posted by Sandy Vagina:
Guy makes 100+ mil by age 33... what a silly joke. Imagine the meth, courage, and real love you could have pretended to have with all that, SDH. :-)

( i mean, aside from the internet, lmao )
And also gets two scoops of CTE in every box!
[Reply]
Rasputin 12:18 PM 01-20-2018
Originally Posted by JENKINSWINS:
People keep bringing up that meaningless game. If anything you Mahomosexuals should know that Mahomes has more chemistry with 2nd and 3rd stringers.
Meaningless? Beating Denver in Denver with a rookie quarterback giving him experience meaningless? Not hardly. He practiced with the ones at TC so yeah he would have destroyed the Broncos in Denver if he had the starters especially Kelce and Tyreek Hill.


Just wait till next year oh wait you will follow Alex Smith to the Browns or wherever he goes so you will miss out on the Patrick Mahomes II Soul Train.
[Reply]
Page 7 of 8
« First < 34567 8 >
Up