Originally Posted by dlphg9:
Would you guys rather make the playoffs this year and be eliminated in the 1st round or get the number 1 pick and he's guaranteed to be Max Scherzer?
Seems a clear winner would be to get the Scherzer clone. But that’s quite the guarantee. [Reply]
Originally Posted by dlphg9:
Would you guys rather make the playoffs this year and be eliminated in the 1st round or get the number 1 pick and he's guaranteed to be Max Scherzer?
That's a question?
Take the 'guaranteed to be Scherzer' out of the equation and just say it's Kumar Rocker and I'd take Rocker an the risk associated with pitching prospects over a 1st round exit.
You could trade Rocker the moment he's eligible to be traded and get one of the best young established veterans in the game. There are maybe 10 pitchers that wouldn't get moved for him. I'd say Snell is probably as close as you get to borderline and then just because of some odd injury history.
I wouldn't trade Flaherty for him, Dodgers probably wouldn't move Buehler. But you could get guys like Paddack and Alcantara for him pretty easily I would think. A guy like Beiber is probably right at the borderline.
His immediate value, irrespective of the 'prospect' risk, is so immense that you absolutely take him over a 1 and done. [Reply]
I agree with you guys and its not even close, but what if it's not a guaranteed 1st round exit and anything can happen. Does that change your mind? [Reply]
Originally Posted by lewdog:
6 teams have positive players?
Did they spend a month arguing for a season that might not even happen?
That is exactly what they did. I bet we are 8-2 when the season is called. Tied for first in the A.L. therefore World champions. Sorry, no parade. [Reply]
Originally Posted by dlphg9:
Would you guys rather make the playoffs this year and be eliminated in the 1st round or get the number 1 pick and he's guaranteed to be Max Scherzer?
Originally Posted by dlphg9:
I agree with you guys and its not even close, but what if it's not a guaranteed 1st round exit and anything can happen. Does that change your mind?
Originally Posted by Bearcat:
2014 Wildcard game on FS1.... it's one of the 3 sports channels I still get on Dish.
I had to switch to Directv.
I couldn’t stand another year without the Royals much less than without the NFLN. It’s a shame because I like the Dish Hopper better than the Directv Genie. [Reply]