ChiefsPlanet Mobile
View Poll Results: Alex Smith's Grade Card
Part 1: Grade for the 2017 Season 1 0.72%
A+ 4 2.88%
A 17 12.23%
A- 21 15.11%
B+ 45 32.37%
B 23 16.55%
B- 6 4.32%
C+ 2 1.44%
C 4 2.88%
C- 3 2.16%
D+ 2 1.44%
D 0 0%
D- 0 0%
F 8 5.76%
No grade 0 0%
Part 2: 2017 Performance Relative to Expectations 1 0.72%
Greatly exceeded my expectations 38 27.34%
Slightly exceeded my expectations 76 54.68%
Performed about like I expected 13 9.35%
Performed slightly worse than my expectations 1 0.72%
Performed far short of my expectations 4 2.88%
Part 3: Desired Role for 2018 1 0.72%
Much larger 1 0.72%
Slightly larger 1 0.72%
About the same as 2017 4 2.88%
Slightly smaller 1 0.72%
Much smaller 7 5.04%
Off the team 116 83.45%
Part 4: I think this player’s ability is … 2 1.44%
Ascending 11 7.91%
Stable 87 62.59%
Descending 34 24.46%
Part 5: The minimum I would trade this player for is a mid- … 1 0.72%
-sized bottle of Pibb Extra 11 7.91%
7th round pick 2 1.44%
6th round pick 0 0%
5th round pick 2 1.44%
4th round pick 3 2.16%
3rd round pick 35 25.18%
2nd round pick 69 49.64%
1st round pick 17 12.23%
A pair of 1st round picks 4 2.88%
I would not trade this player 2 1.44%
Part 6: I prefer… 1 0.72%
Great Pyramid 61 43.88%
Great Wall 45 32.37%
Multiple Choice Poll. Voters: 139. You may not vote on this poll
Page 5 of 8
< 12345 678 >
Nzoner's Game Room>Chiefs Offseason Planet Evaluation: Alex Smith
Rain Man 07:10 PM 01-18-2018
Even the MVP must get a grade card. Let the world know what you think.

Alex played in 15 games with 15 starts this season (sitting out one game to watch the Ghost of Christmas Future). He completed 341 passes at a 67.5% completion rate, for 4,402 yards and 8.0 yards per attempt. He threw 26 touchdown passes and 5 interceptions. His quarterback rating was 104.7.

Atop that, he ran for 355 yards and 1 TD, at 5.9 yards per rush.
[Reply]
Hammock Parties 10:46 AM 01-19-2018
Originally Posted by JENKINSWINS:
You're a joke. There were at least 5 drops that would've been TDs. So, he would've had more TDs. He also sat out of that meaningless game Mahomes played in. :-)
Drops don't happen to other quarterbacks! :-)

The Chiefs did not have an issue with drops. They were above league average.

What about dropped picks? You want I should throw those in, too? If the Pats don't drop a pick six in the opener the Chiefs lose. If the Raiders don't drop a pick, Albert Wilson doesn't score a fluke TD.

Cretin.
[Reply]
JENKINSWINS 11:07 AM 01-19-2018
Originally Posted by Hammock Parties:
Drops don't happen to other quarterbacks! :-)

The Chiefs did not have an issue with drops. They were above league average.

What about dropped picks? You want I should throw those in, too? If the Pats don't drop a pick six in the opener the Chiefs lose. If the Raiders don't drop a pick, Albert Wilson doesn't score a fluke TD.

Cretin.
How do they lose, they smoked the Pats by more than a TD? That right there tells me what I need to hear from you or don't need to. You aren't very smart.
[Reply]
bigjosh 11:09 AM 01-19-2018
Originally Posted by JENKINSWINS:
How do they lose, they smoked the Pats by more than a TD? That right there tells me what I need to hear from you or don't need to. You aren't very smart.
minus 6(7) from one team and add 6(7) to the other team, that is a 12 to 14 point swing, including extra points. 12-14 point difference.

Basic math.
[Reply]
JENKINSWINS 11:11 AM 01-19-2018
Originally Posted by bigjosh:
minus 6(7) from one team and add 6(7) to the other team, that is a 12 to 14 point swing, including extra points. 12-14 point difference.

Basic math.
So that guarantees they lose that game? :-)
[Reply]
Hammock Parties 11:13 AM 01-19-2018
Originally Posted by JENKINSWINS:
How do they lose, they smoked the Pats by more than a TD? That right there tells me what I need to hear from you or don't need to. You aren't very smart.
It was 17-7 when it happened.

The Chiefs weren't coming back from 24-7.

Just fuck off with your drops narrative.
[Reply]
The Franchise 11:17 AM 01-19-2018
Originally Posted by Hammock Parties:
A whole one drop per game. And three or four of these were against the Broncos when Mahomes started. LIAR LIAR YOUR PANTS ON FIRE.

Man....I wonder if all of the Blake Bortles' ballwashers bitch about the drops that he has to deal with.
[Reply]
JENKINSWINS 11:22 AM 01-19-2018
Originally Posted by Hammock Parties:
It was 17-7 when it happened.

The Chiefs weren't coming back from 24-7.

Just **** off with your drops narrative.
Well he didn't play in that meaningless game against the Broncos so his numbers are way better than you and a lot of other people would like to give him credit for. Plus the drops I mentioned were just the ones that were 99% TDs had they been caught. That's all I was trying to say.

Hey, the Titans came back from 21-3 deficit so who knows? :-)
[Reply]
Hammock Parties 11:32 AM 01-19-2018
Originally Posted by JENKINSWINS:
Well he didn't play in that meaningless game against the Broncos so his numbers are way better than you and a lot of other people would like to give him credit for. Plus the drops I mentioned were just the ones that were 99% TDs had they been caught. That's all I was trying to say.

Hey, the Titans came back from 21-3 deficit so who knows? :-)
You can say that about a dozen QBs, though.

And if you're going to count dropped TDs, I'm going to count dropped picks. For every dropped TD, there's a stupid YAC play that Smith had nothing to do with, like the shovel passes or that play against Dallas.

It's fucking stupid. He is what he is. Don't try to twist the data to fit your narrative.
[Reply]
JENKINSWINS 11:35 AM 01-19-2018
Originally Posted by Hammock Parties:
You can say that about a dozen QBs, though.

And if you're going to count dropped TDs, I'm going to count dropped picks. For every dropped TD, there's a stupid YAC play that Smith had nothing to do with, like the shovel passes or that play against Dallas.

It's ****ing stupid. He is what he is. Don't try to twist the data to fit your narrative.
I'm not trying to twist anything. I gave him a B+.
[Reply]
Hammock Parties 11:43 AM 01-19-2018
Originally Posted by JENKINSWINS:
I'm not trying to twist anything. I gave him a B+.
Why don't you give yourself a fuck.
[Reply]
ThaVirus 12:11 PM 01-19-2018
Originally Posted by Hammock Parties:
You can say that about a dozen QBs, though.

And if you're going to count dropped TDs, I'm going to count dropped picks. For every dropped TD, there's a stupid YAC play that Smith had nothing to do with, like the shovel passes or that play against Dallas.

It's fucking stupid. He is what he is. Don't try to twist the data to fit your narrative.

We call the the Hill Mary.
[Reply]
TigeRRUppeRRcut 12:35 PM 01-19-2018
Team MVP
[Reply]
Hammock Parties 12:37 PM 01-19-2018
Originally Posted by TigeRRUppeRRcut:
Team MVP
without him how could this team have attained the lofty heights of 9-7?
[Reply]
bigjosh 12:44 PM 01-19-2018
So valuable, that he is expendable.
[Reply]
Sandy Vagina 12:56 PM 01-19-2018
Even in his most hated venue (CP).. the VAST majority believe that this 34 year old, EXPENSIVE starting QB will be worth a minimum of a 2nd rd pick or more.

Seems pretty justified to say he has value and importance. :-)
[Reply]
Page 5 of 8
< 12345 678 >
Up