ChiefsPlanet Mobile
Page 250 of 295
« First < 150200240246247248249250 251252253254260 > Last »
Nzoner's Game Room>****The Clyde Edwards-Helaire Thread*****
Dante84 10:09 PM 04-23-2020
More to come! (I'll clean it up later - info dump into the OP)

(mod edit, all the goodness is in the spoiler tags)
Spoiler!

[Reply]
staylor26 10:26 AM 07-07-2022
Originally Posted by O.city:
Could argue he's been Dexter McCluster 2.0 at this point but with more speed and on a team with better QB'ing.
Yea you could certainly make that dumb argument.
[Reply]
O.city 10:47 AM 07-07-2022
2nd round pick that's underwhelmed and hasn't improved much at the WR spot since his first year and has to be used in gadget type situations to get him the ball?

Seems to fit pretty well?
[Reply]
staylor26 10:50 AM 07-07-2022
Originally Posted by O.city:
2nd round pick that's underwhelmed and hasn't improved much at the WR spot since his first year and has to be used in gadget type situations to get him the ball?

Seems to fit pretty well?
First off, to say that Hardman is "faster" is an understatement. McCluster ran a fucking 4.58. It's not even remotely close. In terms of speed, he's much closer to CEH than Hardman.

Also, McCluster was a flat out bust, unlike Hardman. Hardman has been a productive player from year 1 despite having target monsters in Hill and Kelce to contend with.

They're both 2nd round picks, and they're gadget guys in terms of their roles. The comparison ends there.
[Reply]
staylor26 10:58 AM 07-07-2022
And again, I think Hardman's play down the stretch was overshadowed by the disappointing end to our season as a team.

Even Andy has made it a point that they finally found a groove with him and he was playing his best football. If Mahomes doesn't miss him repeatedly in the 2nd half of the AFCCG, not only would we have been in the SB, Hardman would've been given a lot more credit for his play down the stretch.

Maybe that improvement we've been waiting on finally came, and we will see more of it this season.

I wouldn't be shocked if he's our leading receiver in 2022. He has as good of a shot as anybody. I don't necessarily expect it, but it's absolutely possible.
[Reply]
crispystl 11:02 AM 07-07-2022
Originally Posted by staylor26:
First off, to say that Hardman is "faster" is an understatement. McCluster ran a ****ing 4.58. It's not even remotely close. In terms of speed, he's much closer to CEH than Hardman.

Also, McCluster was a flat out bust, unlike Hardman. Hardman has been a productive player from year 1 despite having target monsters in Hill and Kelce to contend with.

They're both 2nd round picks, and they're gadget guys in terms of their roles. The comparison ends there.
Yeah Hardman is 3x the player McCluster was.
[Reply]
O.city 11:04 AM 07-07-2022
Originally Posted by staylor26:
First off, to say that Hardman is "faster" is an understatement. McCluster ran a ****ing 4.58. It's not even remotely close. In terms of speed, he's much closer to CEH than Hardman.

Also, McCluster was a flat out bust, unlike Hardman. Hardman has been a productive player from year 1 despite having target monsters in Hill and Kelce to contend with.

They're both 2nd round picks, and they're gadget guys in terms of their roles. The comparison ends there.
Statistically, without looking id imagine they're pretty similar.

I've never been much of a Hardman hater as some here. He's been a nice player for the Chiefs. But he hasn't really improved much as a WR from year one to now.
[Reply]
staylor26 11:11 AM 07-07-2022
McCluster first 3 years:

989 rec yards 3 TDs

Hardman first 3 years:

1,791 rec yards 12 TDs


Damn near twice as many yards and 4 times the TDs. Hardman is also a Pro Bowl level returner.
[Reply]
ToxSocks 11:13 AM 07-07-2022
Originally Posted by O.city:
Statistically, without looking id imagine they're pretty similar.
Heh. Then either you're still undervaluing Hardman or way overvalued McCluster. Their production wasn't remotely similar.
[Reply]
O.city 11:26 AM 07-07-2022
Originally Posted by staylor26:
McCluster first 3 years:

989 rec yards 3 TDs

Hardman first 3 years:

1,791 rec yards 12 TDs


Damn near twice as many yards and 4 times the TDs. Hardman is also a Pro Bowl level returner.
Wasn't Dexter a pro bowl returner in 13?

He also had about 600 yards rushing as shitty as he was.

He was also playing with who at QB?
[Reply]
staylor26 11:40 AM 07-07-2022
Originally Posted by O.city:
Wasn't Dexter a pro bowl returner in 13?

He also had about 600 yards rushing as shitty as he was.

He was also playing with who at QB?
Yes, 500 of which came from his sophomore season when they tried to use him as a legit RB.

Here's a funny stat:

McCluster averaged 8.4 YPR

Hardman averages 14.2

But yea, basically the same guy! :-)
[Reply]
O.city 11:44 AM 07-07-2022
Originally Posted by staylor26:
Yes, 500 of which came from his sophomore season when they tried to use him as a legit RB.

Here's a funny stat:

McCluster averaged 8.4 YPR

Hardman averages 14.2

But yea, basically the same guy! :-)
No nuance allowed here huh?

Who was playing QB when Dexter was playing here?
[Reply]
O.city 11:45 AM 07-07-2022
Will Hardman continue his McCluster path and move on after a single rookie contract?
[Reply]
AdolfOliverBush 11:47 AM 07-07-2022
C'mon, McCluster sucked balls. The Chiefs were looking for Dante Hall 2.0, and ended up with Gary Coleman 2.0.
[Reply]
O.city 11:48 AM 07-07-2022
Oh he definitely sucked.

I can't imagine anyone can look at what Hardmans done and think the Chiefs are happy with how it's gone so far though either.
[Reply]
ToxSocks 11:50 AM 07-07-2022
Originally Posted by O.city:
No nuance allowed here huh?

Who was playing QB when Dexter was playing here?
If we're talking nuance, their skill sets aren't even remotely the same.
[Reply]
Page 250 of 295
« First < 150200240246247248249250 251252253254260 > Last »
Up