Originally Posted by Mr. Arrowhead:
Just throwing this theory out there. I know Terez article came out and said Dorsey just did things without telling people. Anyone think Dorsey Cut Maclin behind Reid's back?
I think he definitely did. Reid would have gotten in touch Maclin personally and let him know himself. He was at his wedding a few days before. Andy didn't know I don't think. [Reply]
Originally Posted by DaWolf:
Wait, on one hand we have "the best roster in the NFL" yet on the other hand we are no closer to a Super Bowl than we were back in the Carl days because of critical flaws to the roster, with Carl wanting to build the "best 53, not the best 11". Still starting a middling SF backup, still have no big play WR's, still have RBBC, still can't stop the run or rush the passer in the playoffs.
So Clark can't win either way. He sticks with the guy, we have to make a bunch of cuts next year, have no first round pick, are starting a first time QB, and are no closer to a Super Bowl, and he's just satisfied with filling seats. He gets rid of the guy, and he's "embarrassing" the team.
Clark did not make this move because he has no idea what he is doing. There was probably either a serious issue with Dorsey behind the scenes that led to this, or this was Clark making a decision between Dorsey or Reid (and Reid has done that before in Philly, so it is a possibility). And if it was the latter, Clark was correct in choosing Reid...
I might agree if we didn't just draft a QB in the 1st round [Reply]
Originally Posted by Tuckdaddy:
I think he definitely did. Reid would have gotten in touch Maclin personally and let him know himself. He was at his wedding a few days before. Andy didn't know I don't think.
I find that hard to believe. Dorsey knew Reid was tight with Maclin and they had been at OTAs that week. He wouldn't just not tell Andy he was cutting him loose.
Reid knew they were shopping him...my guess is Reid was playing good cop to keep the locker room from being upset.
There was a lot of turnover this year...Charles, Poe, Howard, and Maclin. Four deaths in the "family"....
If anything, Dorsey getting fired might be partially due to how he ended the relationships with core players. That's purely speculation but Charles was miffed as was Maclin. Neither were given the opportunity to renegotiate...not that it would have helped. [Reply]
Originally Posted by O.city:
That or Reid power played it.
Those are the only 2 things that make any sense to me
I really, really don't think Reid had a thing to do with this.
If he did, they wouldn't be interviewing guys from outside that he has zero ties to. They'd just hire Veach after interviewing to comply with Rooney rule. [Reply]
Originally Posted by The Bad Guy:
I really, really don't think Reid had a thing to do with this.
If he did, they wouldn't be interviewing guys from outside that he has zero ties to. They'd just hire Veach after interviewing to comply with Rooney rule.
I'm sure he talked with Hunt about the Maclin situation. You think he'd keep quiet? Doubt it. [Reply]
Idk why but I do feel like there is a strong possibility that Dorsey straight up cut Maclin without telling Andy. Maybe be mentioned it to him before so he wasn't completely blindsided about it, but make no mistake Andy was ****ing livid at OTA's after that move. You could tell something more was there.
With Dorsey supposedly doing things without telling people and Andy calling Maclin right after to console him, it really makes this seem like a god guess.
The Maclin debacle ended Dorsey's time here. He had to have really ****ed that entire situation up. [Reply]
Originally Posted by RunKC:
Idk why but I do feel like there is a strong possibility that Dorsey straight up cut Maclin without telling Andy. Maybe be mentioned it to him before so he wasn't completely blindsided about it, but make no mistake Andy was ****ing livid at OTA's after that move. You could tell something more was there.
With Dorsey supposedly doing things without telling people and Andy calling Maclin right after to console him, it really makes this seem like a god guess.
The Maclin debacle ended Dorsey's time here. He had to have really ****ed that entire situation up.
The one thing that struck me as "odd" in the Maclin deal was...he was out there practicing all week. He could have injured himself then been cut....not sure what type of insurance he carries but it was kind of a shitty deal. Maybe in Dorsey's mind...he was giving him one last chance to be on the team. Reid knew he was being shopped as I mentioned. After he heard back from the coaches..he decided to release him. [Reply]
Originally Posted by BlackOp:
The one thing that struck me as "odd" in the Maclin deal was...he was out there practicing all week. He could have injured himself then been cut....not sure what type of insurance he carries but it was kind of a shitty deal. Maybe in Dorsey's mind...he was giving him one last chance to be on the team. Reid knew he was being shopped as I mentioned. After he heard back from the coaches..he decided to release him.
Like you said, I too now believe that Dorsey was practicing Bill B.-type cutting and negotiation, and that it came to a head during his discussions with Clark.
I'm fairly positive that Clark doesn't want the Chiefs to become known as a ruthless franchise where long term players are shown the door on the fly.
Personally, I think that style is long overdue in KC after years of trying to milk the last drops of talent from several old cows. [Reply]
Dorsey forced himself out. Running the risk of a Maclin injury during OTA's is inexcusable if you are apparently in that bad of a cap situation because had he gotten hurt, who are we cutting? He goes to as some people mentioned more of a cut throat scenario, which is contrary to what he did when he first got here.
We are all sitting here saying screw Clark, blah blah blah but I believe Dorsey may have been doing the things he has been doing as he thought no chance they cut me and if they do they look foolish (which we do). It was lose lose for Clark, but I don't believe Reid or any of them or as upset about it as we are. Besides overpaid Tampa of course. [Reply]
Originally Posted by RunKC:
Idk why but I do feel like there is a strong possibility that Dorsey straight up cut Maclin without telling Andy. Maybe be mentioned it to him before so he wasn't completely blindsided about it, but make no mistake Andy was ****ing livid at OTA's after that move. You could tell something more was there.
With Dorsey supposedly doing things without telling people and Andy calling Maclin right after to console him, it really makes this seem like a god guess.
The Maclin debacle ended Dorsey's time here. He had to have really ****ed that entire situation up.
Yup just with the story Terez put out about dorsey doing shit without telling people, it makes sense. Then factor in the him and clark butting heads with the Berry negotiations combined with maybe cutting maclin on his own, then it kind of all makes sense now. [Reply]
Originally Posted by 65TPT:
They may have wanted to see if Maclin was back to true form and he just plain sucked and was beat out.
I think that was the case...in Dorsey's defense, Maclin earned his release. I think he was giving him the chance to re-claim his spot. It's his job to protect the team...not Maclin's feelings. They paid him like $20 million...he'll have a nice life.
Having a "family" atmosphere is admirable but not at the expense of making to correct moves to build a championship caliber team. [Reply]